Vol. 114


DOES CINEMA JUST LIVE IN THE PRESENT?

A CONVERSATION WITH JEROME CHARYN





Born and raised in the Bronx, Jerome Charyn graduated from Columbia College
cum laude, Phi Beta Kappa. His first novel was published in 1964, and today his literary output is well over fifty books. From 1995 to 2008, he was Professor of Film Studies at the American University in Paris. In 1996, he published the book Movieland: Hollywood and the Great American Dream Culture. Charyn is one of the true literary icons of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, and an expert on movies and Hollywood. One of his most recent books, Big Red, and is about twentieth-century movie star Rita Hayworth. His memoir about his mother, A Singular Beauty, was published by Stay Thirsty Press.

STAY THIRSTY: Does cinema have a history, or does it just live in the present?

JEROME CHARYN: Both answers are correct. I remember that as a child I saw every film that was made. If you went to the movies twice a week, you could catch everything that every studio did. And I fell in love with Abbott and Costello, with Danny Kaye, with Betty Hutton, and I thought that they were immortal, that they would remain with us for the rest of our lives. They were part of our everyday history, and they've completely disappeared. The only thing we remember of Abbott and Costello is that joke, "Who's on First?" History has a strange way of creating a kind of amnesia as we move from generation to generation.

At the same time, the two most influential films, Citizen Kane and Pulp Fiction, their auras still exist. But if you went to a young person today, would they really know about Citizen Kane or Pulp Fiction? They would maybe know about films that are derived from them. All they would be thinking about is Spider-Man.

So, in other words, what lasts and what doesn't last is a very, very strange phenomenon. We live in a culture of amnesia, where one generation wipes out the next.


STAY THIRSTY: Who is the keeper of the flame on the history of film, who can sit down and say Citizen Kane was the beginning of the following elements, or Pulp Fiction was a change in the culture of film, and these things derive from it? Where does that repose?


Orson Welles from Citizen Kane

JEROME CHARYN: I'm the keeper of the flame. On the other hand, so are all those who study film and consider themselves cinéastes, or lovers of film.

Look at what's remained. What's remained out of the past is really one thing: film noir, because it's more contemporary than contemporary. Most films made in their own time don't last because the screen is a kind of skin. It reflects the aura of its own time, and when that time fades, the film often fades with it.

We think of Humphrey Bogart as a star of the ages. But after he died, he was completely forgotten. And then I remember that they began Humphrey Bogart festivals. People go in and out of history. Some people create a kind of mythology around them, such as Bogart, and they last, but most others don't. Now we have festivals around Robert Mitchum. Because of the different platforms that we have today, the echo of the past seems to come back. But in general, there is a cultural amnesia.


STAY THIRSTY: Do film directors think back to the origins that they're going to build on or are they really trying to cut new cloth or don't care?

JEROME CHARYN: I think the really good filmmakers have gone to film schools and know the past of cinema, just as writers and students of writing go back to other novelists of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.

Cinema is a new art. It's the art of the twentieth century, and it expands in so many different directions. It's a kind of octopus, with relentless feelers that attach themselves, and some of them disappear. Time is just such a strange phenomenon. What's relevant today doesn't matter tomorrow, and what's relevant tomorrow may not be relevant three days later. There is no longer any cultural currency. We live in an age of forgetfulness.


STAY THIRSTY: Is this true of other art forms, whether it's art or literature?

JEROME CHARYN: Yes. Do we see much about painting anymore? Thirty years ago, painting was the rage. You had all of these painters who were coming out of the woodwork, mostly male. Now there are also many women. But the forms of art change, and now we have multipurpose art: cinema and live action. And look at opera, look at what's happening to opera. Opera goes back all the way to the seventeenth century, and now we're in the twenty-first century and new operas are being formed, and the old repertoires remain. But it's a constant art that's no longer constant.


STAY THIRSTY: Given the diversity of all the platforms, what are the possibilities for young people just getting into college and wanting to have a career as a filmmaker?

JEROME CHARYN: Well, they have to break through. Look at the film Nomadland, which won the Academy Award in 2020, made by a young Asian American filmmaker. It was a film that I could barely watch. Lenore and I put it on, and it was so distressing. We watched it for two minutes, then we watched it again, and then we realized that it was an extraordinary film.

It was a film that was saying no to our culture. These were nomads who were not going to be part of the kind of enriched society that we all live in. They rejected it. And it was a beautiful film. It was a disruptive film. It was an annoying film. It was a wonderful film. And of course it broke through. It won the Academy Award for Frances McDormand and for the young Asian American filmmaker, Chloé Zhao. It was a film that Frances McDormand wanted to do. She was a producer. She had material that was relentless and powerful and heartbreaking, and when you watch that film, it's so disturbing. And yet it's so essential. It says, "I want out."

Things do break through, but they are rarities. How many other young filmmakers are on their seventeenth film that's shown at a festival in Toledo, and we never hear about it? And then suddenly they appear on Netflix, and either they catch an audience or they don't.

What is powerful for young filmmakers is that there are now so many platforms, from smaller channels to larger channels. People need content; people need material. I think there is a hopeful sign for young filmmakers – not about making money, but about having their work shown.


STAY THIRSTY: If you go back and look at Katharine Hepburn, she had the rights to The Philadelphia Story, and she was the producer on it. She did it her way. In essence, she was not only the star, but she was the filmmaker – different from thinking of a filmmaker as merely a director.


Gary Grant, Katharine Hepburn, James Stewart from The Philadelphia Story

JEROME CHARYN: Yes. But you're talking about Katharine Hepburn in The Philadelphia Story: her clout was through being the producer. In other words, golden-age Hollywood was not about directors or stars. It was about producers.

The producers were the real creators, or inventors. Just look at Gone with the Wind. There were seventeen directors on that film, and it was a producer's phenomenon.

In other words, if you have the money, if you have the clout, if you have the stamina – and remember, in any art form, and cinema is like any other art form, you have to be willing to fail. You have to say, "This is what I want to do, and I'm going to do it," and you have to persist. And in this world, where you have so many streaming platforms and so many apps, one can succeed if you can navigate well. It's a question of navigation, and it's always been that way.


STAY THIRSTY: The lock the distributors have had for the last fifty years on what films get into the theaters may have changed because of the streaming platforms.

JEROME CHARYN: Yes. We don't know what the future of theaters is. We know that Marvel and DC have really sort of monopolized the films that go into the cinemas and it's usually kids who see Spider-Man for the fiftieth time that create that aura. But where does the adult audience live? Maybe they get an app and they see film noir, or they go on Netflix, or they go on Amazon.

For example, Lenore and I just watched Pretty Woman, which we had completely forgotten about, and we adored it. And then we watched Moonstruck, and it wasn't a comedy, but all we did was laugh for about a half hour.

So we have the ability to go back into the past, if we know what that past is. But you need that entry point. It's a kind of multiverse, where you can survive and become enriched if you have the memory. If you don't, then you sort of remain in a kind of dark age.


STAY THIRSTY: What are your five most favorite movies?

JEROME CHARYN: Well, that's very, very interesting. I would have to say Citizen Kane. I would have to say Pulp Fiction. I would have to say Chinatown. I would have to say The Maltese Falcon. And I would have to say Out of the Past. Those would be – film noir is really what I believe in. And maybe I would throw in a film by Kubrick.


STAY THIRSTY: If you had an opportunity to make a film today, what would you make?

JEROME CHARYN: If I were to make a film, I would go back to the thirties. I think the greatest animation we had came from Disney in the thirties. Go look at Pinocchio, look at Bambi, look at Dumbo, look at Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. The art in those films is incredible. It's never been matched. It doesn't matter what kind of capabilities we have now. We need an extraordinary artist to create the art.


STAY THIRSTY: In addition to being a film expert, you are also a literary icon. Of all the books you've written, which one would you like to see made into a film?

JEROME CHARYN: Well, I would like to see Big Red, which is about Orson Welles and Rita Hayworth, made into a film, because I think that Rita Hayworth has really been maligned in a way. She was the greatest dancer we ever had in Hollywood. Fred Astaire did two films with her and then wouldn't do any more, because she just made him look like an idiot. She was too good. She was just too good and too sad. She'd had a horrible history. I would love to see a film based on her, and her power and her deep sadness.



Link:

Jerome Charyn




All opinions expressed are solely those of its author and do not reflect the opinions of Stay Thirsty Media, Inc.